Comics that will never be films


A History of Violence, David Boring, Jimmy Corrigan, the Smartest Kid on Earth

Are you fed up with Hollywood co-opting every marketable idea in popular entertainment and releasing a butchered, half-baked version of the original you know and love? Everyone’s heard that “the book is better” but that isn’t so much a truism as a testament to the challenges of adaptation. It’s possible to make an adaptation that surpasses the creative vision of the original.

For an example, look no further than the film version ofA History of Violence.” While the original comic book is straight up pulp crime melodrama, director David Cronenberg created a film adaptation that meditates on the nature of conflict and the motivations of violence. Where the comic exploitatively reveled in the graphic violence that its characters inflicted, the film lingered on the brief brutal moments of bloodshed so as to make you squirm at the horror of it.

The rigidity of film structure and the expense of the moviemaking process make good adaptations few and far between. “The Last Airbender” was an embarrassment. Anything written by Alan Moore—even “Watchmen” and “V for Vendetta”—has been drained of its originality. All “Iron Man” fans care about is whether or not they got his glowing chest insignia right.

What I offer you today is an escape. Here are four comics that couldn’t be adapted to films, even if Zach Snyder was given 500 million dollars to write, produce and direct it.  They’re either unmarketable, unfilmable or too damn smart for their own good. But they’re all brilliant in their original form.

1. “Promethea” by Alan Moore and J.H. Williams

The story starts off as a hilarious romp in futuristic New York, then abruptly becomes a philosophical discussion of reality. The main character, a girl who becomes the incarnation of a female spirit of creativity, starts out as a superhero and ends up as a goddess. Frankly, the middle of the series lags, as its protagonists spend most of their time walking through the multiverse talking about Moore’s trippy religion, but J.H. Williams’ art is some of the best ever seen in comics. And the insane visual homages and literary references are exactly what make the series unadaptable.

2. Weathercraft by Jim Woodring

Woodring’s latest comic in the “Frank” series is a full-length graphic novel, and as usual, it’s like Looney Tunes from another dimension. The whole thing is wordless and populated by symbolist archetypes that manipulate each other in alternately hilarious and gruesome ways. The series is far too weird to be made into a mainstream movie, though an Adult Swim cartoon would not be out of the question. If you like clever social commentary with a side of LSD, I recommend you start with “The Portable Frank” and work your way through the series.

3. “Jimmy Corrigan, the Smartest Kid on Earth” by Chris Ware

Ware is a designer at heart, so half the fun of reading his work is the creative, inventive layout. Any adaptation of his work would lose the visual juxtaposition that permeates his work. Even without that, “Jimmy” is far too depressing to be made into a movie. The story follows not at smart boy but a rather underdeveloped middle-aged shut -n as he stumbles through his sad little life, coupled with the childhood development of his grandfather in the early 1900s. The two storylines converge in the wordless, sprawling climax that confounds description. Hollywood likes a little glimmer of hope in its stories and Ware doesn’t offer any, but the story is beautiful and should be read by anyone who hasn’t yet been convinced of the medium’s maturity.

David Boring4. David Boring by Dan Clowes

Clowes wrote “David Boring” to be a story that couldn’t be adapted into a film, and ironically it could actually be a pretty great one. To do so would counter the spirit of the story, however, which is a self-aware commentary on the nature of storytelling and genre conventions. The eponymous protagonist is constantly avoiding narrative structure, seeking only the presence of his ideal female fantasy. The story begins as an offbeat noir, then switches from romance to horror to thriller and back again. Toward the end of the story Boring struggles to write a screenplay that “follows all the conventions” but can’t seem to put a single word to the page.

Hollywood would like you to believe that nothing is legitimately popular until they’ve turned it into a blockbuster, but I think you’ll find after reading a few of these that film in its current form is restrictive, and movie adaptations mostly cynical economic ventures. If we want our movie culture to grow as a medium, we must demand higher quality and original ideas. Vote with your wallet by seeing “Inception.”

-Guest Blogger Sam Julian

Leave a Reply

Recent Posts From:

  • About Become

    Become, Inc. was founded in 2004 with the goal of helping people make better buying decisions through a price comparison service. Fast forward to 2012, and Become is still ranked one of the top 10 comparison shopping search engines online. Finding what you want at the best price point to save you time and money is our goal. Visit and learn about the innovative new technologies in the works!

Copyright © 2006-2014 Become, Inc.